Duck poachers who posted YouTube video plead guilty in Saskatoon court



Duck poachers who posted YouTube video plead guilty in Saskatoon court

Duck poachers who posted YouTube video plead guilty in Saskatoon court

Published on August 10, 2009
Published on November 3, 2009
The Canadian Press ~ The News  RSS Feed

Three young men who filmed themselves gleefully blasting ducks out of a Saskatchewan pond and then posted the video on YouTube were fined thousands of dollars Monday.

David Fraser, James Fraser and Jeremy Rowlands pleaded guilty in a Saskatoon court to breaking several federal and provincial wildlife laws in an incident that sparked widespread public outrage.

Topics :
Saskatchewan Wildlife Federation , Environment Canada , Saskatoon , Saskatchewan , Alberta

SASKATOON -

Three young men who filmed themselves gleefully blasting ducks out of a Saskatchewan pond and then posted the video on YouTube were fined thousands of dollars Monday.

David Fraser, James Fraser and Jeremy Rowlands pleaded guilty in a Saskatoon court to breaking several federal and provincial wildlife laws in an incident that sparked widespread public outrage.

The video, which was shown in court, shows the men cheering each other on as at least two of them use rifles to shoot the ducks and ducklings.

Justice Doug Agnew called their actions "stupid, reckless and irresponsible," and fined the Frasers $5,000 each and Rowlands $6,000 and also ordered them to turn over the rifles.

The men stood side by side in court and apologized for their behaviour. Earlier, they had tried to shield their faces as they rushed out of the courthouse.

They pleaded guilty to unlawful hunting, hunting out of season, discharging a firearm from a vehicle and leaving edible game to be wasted.

The maximum penalty is $100,000 for the provincial offences and $300,000 under federal laws, with the possibility of six months jail time.

Darrell Crabbe, executive director of the Saskatchewan Wildlife Federation, said even hunters were outraged by the case because what the trio did was both illegal and immoral.

"I was disgusted," he said of his reaction to first seeing the video. "Those birds were moulting at that time. Of course, the young are unable to fly anyway. It's all about the ethics in this situation."

"The hunting fraternity in Saskatchewan and other conservationists really jumped on board. It was great to see so many people focused in on this. The ethical hunting community really took this upon themselves to make this right."

Brian Petrar with Environment Canada said the case really had nothing to do with hunting.

"It was people using birds as target practice," he said outside court.

An investigation was started last week after the video surfaced.

Authorities did not know the location where the shooting happened but suspected it was somewhere in Saskatchewan or Alberta because there was a road sign visible and there were blooming fields of canola in the background.

The video prompted a flood of tips from the public.

Comments

  • Username
    gerrie
    - November 20, 2009 at 08:37:05

    people pleassssseeee, we are talking about the men that broke provincial and federal laws . how did this go from commenting on larry,darryl and darryl to screaming racism,strapping and cree way gas bar???? this issue has nothing to do with any of these things. don bird you your self spout hypocrocy, i hope i spelt that right teacher. you have issues and if this is what you teach in your classes then i'm glad my kids go school in the city!! it seems to me that you don't know dippty do dah, i try to listen to all comments about native and white issues and try to come away with something positive. but thats next to impossible thanx to people like you. as for an indian from sk why do you always have to bring race into a subject?? if they had an article about the you pick strawberry farm i just bet you would have some sort of arguement. by the way my reserve owns cree way gas bar!!!!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    an indian says
    - November 20, 2009 at 05:17:34

    I went to a white school before and strapped the hell out of me.White teachers,this was a white female teacher,she's now dead.This should be a reminder of what we as Students growing-up in white schools had to endure.I'd rather have Mr.Bird teaching my children,instead of a white person.This is how it was.White schools treat white students differently.The only people got strapped were Aboriginals,because if there were any white folk who got the strap,by a white teacher, I've never heard of once,then by all rights,please do tell me I'm wrong,because the teacher made sure she made us cry.My accusation is true,if you want we can prove this.Aboriginal students fought thier way through the whiteman schools.We all have similar stories.Once word got out about the strappings.The federal Government made laws afterwards to ban the strap from the education system.And as the white teacher,in my own opinion,and my experience.The white teacher does treat white pupils rather differently.I'm sorry if it seems I'm accusing you,because that was my intent.Our Leaders went through the same system and because of it we have First Nations schools,so we would never have to put our children in harms way.Hears one more as the teacher put it manor is spelt manner.For a teacher you teach this to your pupils.Laughing my blank-off

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    lobo
    - November 20, 2009 at 03:22:50

    I agree with you Connie! The Herald should keep a closer eye on some of these comments. The herald is very quick to delete comments that speak against their buddies and those that call their own ethics into question, including snail mail letters to the editor. I know many people including myself that have written letters to the herald, that have never seen the light of a Daily Herald page. The herald picks and chooses what it decides to print and from whom! I believe the herald actually enjoys creating the division that we see on these pages regularly. To say that the herald is the paper of record of Prince Albert is a joke.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    an indian
    - November 20, 2009 at 01:33:51

    A ruler come on a ruler you make me laugh,I'm talking about an inch thick strap.A ruler, you were treated like a baby I guess.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    dipsy
    - November 20, 2009 at 01:24:51

    It's funny to me that you would lash out at a complete stranger, for anything you could come up with. Spelling mistakes, how much punishment they took, etc. This is just an example of how you don't want things to change. You want to continue the uncomfortable relationship between aboriginals and white people. What you don't see is that there are many people out there who are NOT racist. And that a racist aboriginal is NO BETTER than a racist white man. You're right. I made a spelling mistake. I have made a lot of mistakes through my life, and I'm sure I'll continue to make more. Because that's part of life and learning and growing- making mistakes, and learning from them.
    I will also tell you that in my teaching career I have taught numerous aboriginal students, and have always been well liked by students and parents alike. I have also had co-workers who are aboriginal, and I consider them my friends, and know they would say the same about me. There are many good people no matter where you look, in every race... but for some reason we focus on the bad ones, and they're the ones we remember. The drunk, the thief, the racist, the abuser. We never remember the gentleman, the good father or mother, the scholar or hardworker.
    We need to change how we think, and put value on all human life.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Just Me
    - November 20, 2009 at 00:11:52

    Not sure where in this story Residential Schools, teaching on a reserve or not, Indians being treated unfairly comes into play. So typical of the rants we have to endure on this site. Mr. Bird if you have such a huge problem with the way society is, then make changes, but promoting hatred and racism is not the correct way to go about it.

    Maybe the Judge should put these young fellas in a pond and then shoot at them, see how they like it!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    B
    - November 19, 2009 at 23:40:46

    I respect your opinions and that you're angry. I know that there are many injustices directed at aboriginal people, as well as others of different races, religions, sexual orientations, etc. There are injustices directed at white christian heterosexuals. My point is, this province, this country, this world- it's all going to hell in a handbasket and no one seems to be able to see past their own hurts to try to stop it. And I'm not saying that you're not justified to be hurt. I am not going to get into race relations here. What I do want to say is that we need to come together as a whole, and work together to try to find peace and harmony so that all people can live safely and happily, without fear of persecution because they might be different from their neighbour.

    And, aside from all that, this article is about 3 men who did something horrible, and thought they should post it for the world to see, without
    any thought as to the consequences.
    Now, let me get this straight. They are knowledgable enough to use a video camera, to download the video to the internet, and to post it on youtube... but they had no clue what they were doing was illegal. I can smell the BS from here. Obviously, their elevator isn't reaching the top floor though... I mean, what did they think would happen after they posted their video. I hope they get a suitable sentence, and that maybe, just maybe people could learn from this!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Shame On You Three
    - November 19, 2009 at 23:34:01

    100% PURE IDIOTS

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Ed lives
    - November 19, 2009 at 23:18:59

    blah blah here we go with the race thing. Like what are you talking about..... Speaking of no brainer or is it brainless

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Just Me
    - November 19, 2009 at 22:20:04

    I love Cree-Way Gas Bar, they are the best!

    I think it is time Daily Herald deletes deletes deletes some of these comments!

    And c'mon ppl lets get back on topic, I am for one tired of all the racism PA has to endure FROM ALL SIDES.

    As for those hunters the embarrassment and harassment they are now facing....good for them, maybe next time they won't be so idiotic. What a complete disregard for Mother Nature.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    umm
    - November 19, 2009 at 18:35:39

    did i not say the strap as well or did u miss that in ur rambling....and an inch of wood or an inch of leather, hurts all the same, you always have an answer that all natives were hit harder and more often and wah wah wah but have never actually talked to anyone who wasnt native to find out how half the other side lives but how can you talk to a race u so openly despise...

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Corrine
    - November 19, 2009 at 18:13:32

    I think the Herald should be removing some of the posts on here and keeping an eye on the comments. It is absolutely disgusting to read!!

    Shame on the 3 guys that did this crime. They knew what they were doing and the playing dumb act is just a game to get out of trouble.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    an indian
    - November 19, 2009 at 17:56:21

    It would of been harsher,if it were a indian,but at onetime not to long ago a Aboriginal was charged over tens of thousands.And that indian was hunting for sustinance indians aren't this way.But we still get charged more severely than others.I guess Ontario doesn't have any animals,just guns to shoot people.The ducks were used as targets for other reasons to not know better.Another no brainer.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Gord
    - November 19, 2009 at 17:47:13

    Moe, Curly and the other guy, what a trio of absolute morons. Can you believe they did this... posted it on utube then suggest they didn't know they were doing anything wrong. I mean really the only thing missing is the banjo....

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    dipsy
    - November 19, 2009 at 15:30:42

    Mr. Bird, may I ask... do you teach on a reserve? If so, do you teach your students the things that you've mentioned on here? And if you do not teach on the reserve, how do you treat white students? their parents?
    I am also a teacher, and would find it very difficult to treat my students with the respect that I expect from them, if I had such a blatant dislike for them.
    We should all, as teachers, be teaching our students about respect and equality, and tolerance. We should be making sure they understand the history of this province and country, and this should be done without racial undertones.
    I am sorry if it seems I'm accusing you, that's not my intent. I am just interested in how you approach your class in this manor.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    OMG
    - November 19, 2009 at 14:58:19

    OMFG!!! Really! This is about 3 dudes who have never learnt to have any respect!! Indian you are whinning and crying and Don Bird you are being ignorant. Come on ppl. Two the 2 mentioned above do you ever stop and see that somer Native ppl like yourselves are the ones promoting racism and discrimination??? Do you ever find that is part of the problem? Native pple often discriminate against white ppl and you don't ever realize that you are doing it do you??? Like for instance you have all Native schools that only Aboriginal ppl can attend, what if us white folk did that you would cry racism!! If the shoes doesn't fit on the other foot then don't wear it !!!!!! Get a grip dudes and seriously grow up!!

    To Don Bird if you were teaching my kids I would ask to have them removed from your room and file a complaint against you if you were teaching my kids the way that you are talking on here. I teach them respect for all no matter what race and you should learn to do the same you may find that your life is easier!!! Remember that it happened to your ancestors not you, things happened to our ancestors and you don't see us crying the blues!!

    Anyways back to the story, if those boys are stupid enough to put it on Utube then they are stupid enough to get caught. They should take them to the same pond and shoot blanks at them and not tell them that they are blanks and see if they don't sh*t themselves trying to get away, they may learn what it felt like. Poor little ducklings loosing their mommas, they need them! Hope they get what they deserve!!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    simple
    - November 19, 2009 at 10:38:15

    lol . we treat others the way they treat us.
    I guess all of us have had some bad exp with white or aboriginal that is why race comes into play all the time.
    Iam aboriginal and have alot of white freinds .
    as for the 3 imego,s . get over it already.
    it,s done with.leave them alone.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Don
    - November 19, 2009 at 03:24:33

    Just SO you arrogant people wanna think, Im not Don Bird the Provincial Court Judge......I am Don Bird (diff clan.....same name)......I am an Elementary School Teacher!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    And Yet Again
    - November 18, 2009 at 22:17:47

    And watch the hands get slapped and sent on there way cause no judge in Canada can stand up and make an example of these 3 losers!

    Ahhh the Canadian justice system. Slap slap ok now dont do that again go on your way!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    JoPoor
    - November 18, 2009 at 22:07:32

    These guys are NOT HUNTERS!!! THEY ARE POACHERS!!!
    Everyone should be disgusted by the total lack of regard for the law, and lack of respect for the animals.

    These guys make a REAL case for STRICT gunlaws!

    Can we drive by them at court and take pot shots at them from our vehicles?


    I WISH!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    umm
    - November 18, 2009 at 21:30:52

    i know quite a few white kids who got the strap in schools as well as rulers across the hands and arms etc so u obviously are poorly informed. And where did the race come up in this article again, its getting pretty tiring...this has nothign to do with race, but it looks like these people are just going to scream racism on every page

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    nobigsurprise
    - November 18, 2009 at 20:12:40

    Why didn't these village idiots lose their vehicle(s); weapons; and ability for each of them to EVER hunt again?????? I agree with Gord let the banjo begin!!!! Their pathetic plea of I didn't know it was illegal is the biggest joke ever....ummmm okay village idiots how did you come into possession of a weapon without an FAC??? One would only ASSUME at lease one of you hunts seeing as you have a gun to begin with so would only then ASSUME you know there are seasons for every huntable animal...nice try twits! Frankly 5000 and 6000 is far too little for what you did.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Disgusted
    - November 18, 2009 at 16:10:43

    I can not believe the stupidity of these 3 men...and I am completely appalled by their lack of understanding and remorse in this situation... really.... posting the video on youtube... Idiots..

    Secondly...I find that its getting more and more ridiculous to read any article that the herald seems to put out...
    It doesn't matter what the situation or how good the article may be...there is always someone who bends it toward racism..... quite frankly i am sick and tired of it.
    We all long for a day when there will be peace and harmony among the people of Saskatchewan, Of Canada and the world.. but how are we setting the ball in motion.. when every time your turn around the race card is thrown.... I am proud of the province that i live in and I love my city... but its heartbreaking when I mention where I am from and the first thing some one says is racial.... We need to change and it needs to be now....
    The above comments by others do nothing for us.. except promote more anger and hatred.. we wonder what happened to our glorious city, and are quick to blame others... but have we ever looked to ourselves and seen how we are contributing to the problem?

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    lmao
    - November 18, 2009 at 15:58:58

    The middle of the comments really made me laugh. Seems every comment you see about white people you get the indian in there and then it becomes a whole different issue and conversation. We should just have a place on the hearld where you people can rant all you want and leave the actual comments area for the ARTICLE alone! Anyway.. WORLD PEACE! *L*

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Don
    - November 18, 2009 at 14:54:37

    LIKE i've always firmly stood by my GROUND! CANADA is a COMMUNIST COUNTRY ran/goverened by Democrats

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    an indian
    - November 18, 2009 at 13:10:57

    Now Here's a person whose telling it like it is.I totally,absolutely,and Respectfully wish umm would understand.I'm truly sorry.I'm talking to dipsy.Yes I to have a huge amount of White folk friends since childhood.I still say hi to them.No I'm not a racist as Umm may discribe.Thank-you for a very sound advice.Most importantly I made a mistake.To umm,thanks for the good debate.Until next time.I wish for what everyone wants and that's peace and Harmony.That is what we all agreed to in the firstplace Right.Mistake was letting umm get to me.But I can tell what kind of friends umm's are now.

    Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

This form is NOT used for emailing the article to a friend. Please use the "Send to a friend" link at the top of the page for that purpose.

The Prince Albert Daily Herald is not responsible for posted comments. Please be polite and confine your comments to the subject of the posted story. If you have an account, please sign on to it..

(we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising