• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (1)
  •  

Bus safety concerns remain at the research stage

Keegan Wolfe, 13, speaks during this week’s city council meeting about his recent near-death experience. Seen behind him is his mother, Jasmine Robertson and fellow local mothers Cynthia Mamer and Lori Stevenson, from left.  Herald photo by Tyler Clarke

Keegan Wolfe, 13, speaks during this week’s city council meeting about his recent near-death experience. Seen behind him is his mother, Jasmine Robertson and fellow local mothers Cynthia Mamer and Lori Stevenson, from left. 

Tyler Clarke
Published on February 27, 2013
Published on February 27, 2013
Tyler Clarke  RSS Feed

Stepping out from in front of a school bus, Keegan Wolfe was struck by a truck. 

Topics :
Yorkton , Canada

Stepping out from in front of a school bus, Keegan Wolfe was struck by a truck.

“I’m lucky to be alive,” the 13-year-old told the city’s elected officials during this week’s city council meeting.

“It is a parent’s worst nightmare to get a call at work stating that your child has been hit by a vehicle and was being taken to the hospital with unknown injuries,” his mother, Jasmine Robertson, said of the incident, which took place on Jan. 30.

“It is a call that I hope to never have to get again and hope that other parents never have to get, as well.”

The blow was directly to Wolfe’s knee – luckily bending his knee in the correct direction.

“Unfortunately, his knee was severely bruised and he was not able to participate in the many activities he enjoys partaking in at school,” Robertson said.

“I know that this event would not have happened to my son had Bylaw 54 been repealed sooner and education brought out to our schools, homes and people.”

The solution, the two speakers and local mothers Cynthia Mamer and Lori Stevenson told council, is to repeal Bylaw 54, which prohibits school buses from using flashing safety lights and stop arms in city limits.

In October, the city’s last batch of elected officials backed the bylaw’s repealing in principle, placing the implementation of a replacement on the heads of the subsequently elected city council.

It’s more complicated than simply repealing the bylaw, the city’s elected officials told the delegates.

Mayor Greg Dionne noted that a stop arm might provide students with a false sense of security.

Coun. Tim Scharkowski said that he’d like to see more research done regarding the effectiveness of stop arms.

It is a parent’s worst nightmare to get a call at work stating that your child has been hit by a vehicle and was being taken to the hospital with unknown injuries. - Jasmine Robertson

Coun. Ted Zurakowski suggested that a safer approach would be for students to be dropped off on the same side of the street as their destination, cutting out any traffic concerns.

“Do you think it would have been more safe, when you get out of that bus you go straight up to your home, or straight up to your school, rather than crossing the street and walking in front of the bus across the street?” he asked Wolfe.

“Yeah, this wouldn’t have happened,” Wolfe answered.

Currently, school board policy is to drop off students on the correct side of the road whenever possible.

“It may not be convenient, but it’s (always) possible,” Zurakowski said.

Although the delegates urged council to speed up the process, they opted to have administration conduct additional research to determine if the use of stop arms has been demonstrated to reduce accidents and near misses.

If so, they plan on lobbying the provincial government for a uniform provincial approach to the use of these devices in municipalities.

Early on in the presentation, Mamer said that the research has already been done.

“That is why it is mandatory by the Government of Canada that school buses be equipped with these safety features,” she told council.

As part of administration’s research, Coun. Lee Atkinson suggested that Yorkton, which imposed a ban on bus stop arms in loading zones only, be investigated. If Yorkton has found success, he said that their bylaw might be worth emulating. 

Comments

  • Username
    James Kraemer
    - March 15, 2013 at 10:53:20

    The typical crossing procedure is more dangerous than any other event involving the school bus. In the US the red crossing lights and stop sign are ignored by motorists, and huge fines have not ended that oddity. Kids treat the bus lights like a sanctuary, bolting into the road, in the US most years as many or more are struck by their own school bus as are struck by all other motorists combined. Motorists (often teens with riders) crash in to the rear of a stopped school bus, submarine under the stopped bus killing as many or more in the car than crossers. Door side is a very good idea when the transportation provider will do it, many will not citing costs. California manages among the largest school bus transportation systems in the US with among the least bus rider deaths. California requires the bus driver to secure the bus and to then escort the crossers across the road. Whatever the method used requires immediate removal from the bus until fully resolved any child refusing to follow the bus driver's directions. Where that is not policy I fear that more may die crossing in front of the bus than when eliminating the bus as a huge hazard stopped in the road with crossing lights flashing.

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising