• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (13)
  •  

"Stand against the omnibus crime bill," concerned citizens ask Canadians

Concerned local citizens gathered at the office of the MP for Prince Albert, Randy Hoback, on Thursday, to deliver a petition and protest the Conservative government's proposed crime legislation. Herald photo by K.J. Dakin

Concerned local citizens gathered at the office of the MP for Prince Albert, Randy Hoback, on Thursday, to deliver a petition and protest the Conservative government's proposed crime legislation.

Published on November 25, 2011
Published on November 24, 2011
Jason Stockfish  RSS Feed

Joining forces with individuals across Canada on Thursday, were a group of local concerned citizens who went to deliver a petition to the office of Prince Albert’s Conservative Member of Parliament, Randy Hoback, in an effort to get the governing party to reconsider their omnibus crime bill (Bill C-10) that will soon pass through Parliament.

Topics :
Conservatives , Canadian Bar Association , Assembly of First Nations , Ontario , Quebec , Canada

One of the key organizations behind the movement, Leadnow, explains on their website why they have helped to organize over 120 nationwide protests against the Harper government’s proposed crime legislation.

“The Omnibus Crime Bill is a massive combination of bills, all of which failed to pass when the Conservatives had a minority of seats in Parliament.

“When combined, the Crime Bill rejects proven crime prevention and rehabilitation strategies, and instead imposes mandatory sentences that will create hardened criminals, target the most vulnerable in our society, and force prison expansions that will cost our provinces dearly.

“Conservative Texans are warning us not to repeat their mistake. Even they say the crime bill is too harsh, costly and ineffective,” states the group.

“The Canadian Bar Association, representing 37,000 legal professionals, says that through its ‘overreach and overreaction to imaginary problems, Bill C-10 could... eventually create the very problems it’s supposed to solve’.

The organization continues by saying, “Shawn Atleo, the National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, is deeply concerned that the Crime Bill will disproportionately impact First Nations people, and calls for a focus on education.”

“We can do better than the ‘fill-the-prisons’ approach to justice that has failed everywhere.” - Leadnow

“Ontario and Quebec are refusing to pay for a bill (with) mandatory sentences (that) would force costly prison expansion on the provinces, taking resources from crime prevention, rehabilitation and vital services like health and education, adds the group.

As for the number of signatures that have been gathered thus far, the group said, “Over a hundred thousand Canadians have already signed petitions opposing the bill.”

“The Crime Bill is wrong on crime, and tough on democracy, taxpayers, and Canada’s most vulnerable people,” profess the group on their website.

“We are calling on our government to reject the crime bill, and create a Citizen’s Assembly for Canadian Justice that would bring diverse citizens and experts together to create a new plan for Canadian justice,” they add.

“We can do better than the ‘fill-the-prisons’ approach to justice that has failed everywhere,” reads the poster advertising the nationwide event.

See tomorrow’s Herald for a response from the MP for Prince Albert, Randy Hoback.

Jason.Stockfish@Paherald.sk.ca

Comments

  • Username
    Jason Rocklin
    - February 1, 2012 at 14:59:16

    Dear Canadian government: lease do something about preventing crime all over Canada by getting police searching night clubs, bars, highways, streets houses and apartment and banks [i.e.] if the police catches any suspects suspicious of [attempted] child abductions, child abuse, wife assault, murder, animal cruelty and armed bank robberies the police will quickly arrest the suspects, lock them up and throw away the key!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Kathryn McKeown
    - December 13, 2011 at 07:33:46

    This bill will not work to prevent crime and will only make longer court appearances and greater crowded prison for people convicted of less serious crimes. Let create some programs to help the unemployed, people with problems to deal with necessarities of living. Follow Scotland ideas. More prisons will cost so much more, this is not what we voted for. Harper is using his minority to do whatever he wants to this country and we are letting him. No one ever got better in prison. It is time to make some sense before it is too late.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    open your mind
    - November 28, 2011 at 07:57:14

    Crime rates in Canada overall are at their lowest rate since the early 1970's, so why the harsh measures? Yes, people of very modest means can live without resorting to crime, and punishment can be effective where appropriate, but many people are simply born into tough situations with limited opportunity for them to learn a better way. Help and empower them, rather than harden and embitter them. Even the author of the study that the Conservatives relied on while drafting the crime bill said that he thinks the crime bill goes too far. Texas went this route and it failed. Now they are onto something better and have warned us not to follow their former path. Tough love, empowerment and rehabilitation for those that can be reached and saved...it takes more effort and care than just throwing them in jail, but other jurisdictions made the effort and found it works better.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Jay Walker
    - November 28, 2011 at 07:50:51

    Unfortunately, the crime bill won't effectively resolve any of the issues it sets out to, rather, it'll only excarcerbate the problems we already have as a society. And what crimes is it that you posters here are referring to, that have you so concerned? Have you even read the bill? Harper is proposing stiffer sentences for those caught growing their own medicine than those who commit child rape. This is some seriously twisted ideology. Not that I think people who do serious crimes shouldn't be dealt with seriously, but this bill will disproportionately target minorities and people already in marginalized positions who wouldn't be if proper government supports were in place to stop more people from slipping through the cracks. There's a time and place for punishment, but so to is there a time and place for rehabilitation, as well as addressing the root causes (neither of which are things this bill even attempts to do). Yeah, you guys who are championing this bill need to take a closer look. 9 months in jail for 6 Cannabis plants? It's time you people watched the documentary 'Run From The Cure', and also started reading studies like 'Cannabinoids: Potential Anti-Cancer Agents'. Get over it. Cannabis is not a drug. It's an incredibly potent and powerful herbal medicine, that cures cancer. I don't care what absurd ideologies you folks out there have, if I have a terminal disease like cancer, I don't want you or your government cronies in my garden. I want clear and unimpeded access to tried and true plant medicine that works. Stop demonizing medicines you insane fools!

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      Jason Rocklin
      - February 1, 2012 at 15:03:53

      Please do something about preventing attempted murder, attempted child abuse, abduction, attempted wife assault and all other crimes over Canada

  • Username
    Concerned Grandmother
    - November 28, 2011 at 07:48:54

    You are correct, crimes are committed by every colour. There are also lots of people who get by every day on very little money, and God bless them for that. However, I think society should not have to worry all the time that these people who continue to rob, to steal , to drive drunk and kill people, to commit murders, are given little or no time behind bars. In fact they are forgiven time and time, and so many of them do not change their ways ever. Why should they not be behind bars where they cannot hurt anyone else again. If that takes more jails, so be it.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    dan
    - November 28, 2011 at 07:48:24

    A previous post complained about the bill......You say that the bill is not right and crime is low? Walk down Central ave. at 11 pm ...from 15th to River Street and come back to explain to me how your walk was. I hope they have a laptop in the Vic for your response bud!

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      Jason Rocklin
      - February 16, 2012 at 07:42:05

      Dear somebody or the Canadian government: Please do something about preventing homicides, child abductions rape bank robberies, child abuse, wife assault [attempted] all before they all happen over Canada to make people safe all over Canada.

  • Username
    Wetnss
    - November 25, 2011 at 15:06:13

    White, Black, red or green. Don't committ a crime and you've got nothing to worry about. Don't cop out with the racial card or poverty injustice. Lots of people function and live meaningful lives, at or just below the poverty line without pulling a B&E or resorting to substance abuse. Let the Government do their job, govern!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    segun shonde
    - November 25, 2011 at 12:26:04

    The omnibus crime bill doesn't make any sense because the crime rate across Canada is at the lowest in years so can anyone in his/her right mind tell me the justification for this bill.

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      JJ
      - November 28, 2011 at 07:50:42

      As a person who works as a peace officer in our system, I must comment that you should not be fooled by gov't statistics. Organizations putting out info can spin numbers in many different ways to get the results they want. I remember a few years ago when thet stated that drinking and driving was down during one Christmas season. Of course they were down, they set up fewer road side checks where most impaired drivers are caught. The recidivism rate in Canada is recorded as one of the lowest in the western world, however I have seen people who have been in prison most of their adult life but are not considered re-offenders because they never never succeeded in reaching warrant expiry as they pick up new charges on the street everytime they are released. So this person would not show up on recidivism stats, however he/she has re-offended sometimes dozens of times in their life. Be careful with stats. We never worried about locking up everything you owned when we were kids, now you don't dare leave anything left open or unattended. Building more prisons may not be the best solution, however the status quo is also very broken. Our prisons are no detterent as inmates have better living conditions and rights then many tax paying citizens. Trust me I know and the public would be appalled if they knew how badly their tax money was being spent.

    • Username
      Dan
      - November 28, 2011 at 07:48:37

      Crime rate is lower because Harper has put his foot down and the police now have some power. People going to jail are in there longer, instead of the Liberal belief that a crime is the problem created by the victim!!!!! Would you walk down Central avenue at 10 pm on a Saturday night? If you answer yes....then do it bud. I will visit you in the Vic and bring you a Tims.

  • Username
    Concerned Grandmother
    - November 25, 2011 at 12:26:00

    And what does the NDP think the province, and our country should do about the increasing crimes we have.? When people get away with the stuff they do, over and over again and live in our city it makes me very angry. People always excuse it by blaming poverty, they learnt it from their parents, they are addicted, etc, etc. Well that will always be in todays world. Maybe we need more Mental Hospitals, Addiction Hospitals, and put them behind bars like prisons. What are Native Band leaders doing to get parents to do better jobs? Yes, more and more are going back to school, but more and more are also deep in to crimes. Look at the past two weeks in P.A.

    Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

This form is NOT used for emailing the article to a friend. Please use the "Send to a friend" link at the top of the page for that purpose.

The Prince Albert Daily Herald is not responsible for posted comments. Please be polite and confine your comments to the subject of the posted story. If you have an account, please sign on to it..

(we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising